‘We Have Nothing To Battle With, Why Ought to We Go Up Towards Tanks With Solely Machine Weapons?’ Russian Troopers Ask


The video appeared this week on Telegram and different Russian social-media networks: a gaggle of greater than two dozen males in masks and camouflage, standing in a snowy subject and interesting for assist.

“We’re the troopers of the first, third, and 4th Platoons, 254th Regiment, seventh Firm, third Battalion. Please assist us type out the state of affairs,” the troopers say. “Our commander gave us an order to not retreat from our positions. However the commander gave us no cowl and no assist. We had solely machine weapons, and all the remainder of the weapons had been broken.”

“Now they’re accusing us of desertion, for the reason that firm commander says he did not give the order,” they mentioned. “In sum, command does not care about us.”

The video is undated and doesn’t point out the place it was shot, besides to counsel it was in Ukraine or close to staging grounds utilized by Russian forces to enter Ukraine.

However the grievance, and the troopers’ determination to go public with it, highlights the persevering with battlefield issues going through a number of the tens of hundreds of newly mobilized troops that Russian commanders have enlisted to wage warfare in opposition to Ukraine.

In an effort to reverse the navy’s flagging marketing campaign to pound Ukraine into give up, the Kremlin in September ordered the call-up of 300,000 males, lots of them reservists. Within the months prior, Russian authorities had performed what specialists referred to as a “covert mobilization,” recruiting volunteers with affords of excessive salaries.

However Russia’s nationwide logistics and recruiting infrastructure was largely unprepared to take care of the inflow of troops who wanted to be housed, clothed, outfitted, and educated earlier than being deployed.

Troops have complained, even earlier than arriving on the battlefields of japanese Ukraine, of issues like not getting paid, not having sufficient rations, or merely a lack of self-discipline and group amongst commanders.

Desertion Persuasion

A regulation signed by President Vladimir Putin in September stiffens the penalties for desertion throughout a interval of mobilization or wartime, with violators going through as much as 10 years in jail, whereas conscientious objectors will threat as much as three years behind bars. The regulation additionally criminalizes “voluntary” give up, which is punishable by sentences of as much as 15 years.

Nonetheless, that hasn’t dissuaded a rising variety of troopers prepared to courageous the potential of legal fees.

“They had been despatched to the entrance line with solely their bare asses, so to talk, to combat tanks with solely machine weapons,” mentioned Alyona Savochkina, whose husband, Viktor, was one of many troopers showing within the video. “Fundamental package, grenades. All of them. They’d no reinforcements. Nothing.”

In an interview with Present Time, Savochkina, who lives within the western Oryol area, mentioned her husband had beforehand volunteered for service in July and was despatched to work as a driver. However when he was ordered into the infantry, he broke his contract and returned house.

On October 24, she says, he was referred to as up beneath the Kremlin’s mobilization order, and initially despatched to Smolensk, close to the Belarusian border. After a pair extra strikes, his unit was despatched to the entrance line in Ukraine’s Luhansk area on December 31.

Viktor Savochkin

She says her husband’s unit is badly underequipped and underfed. She mentioned they’re equipped with meals gadgets despatched by kin. “However now they’re threatening to deprive them of even this,” she mentioned.

Requested in regards to the troopers’ public enchantment, the regional authorities in Yaroslavl, the place the unit is formally primarily based, mentioned it was investigating the enchantment.

Family of the troopers additionally mentioned they deliberate to file a proper grievance with navy prosecutors in Moscow.

What Are We, Cannon Fodder?

There aren’t any identified figures for what number of Russian troopers have abandoned for the reason that starting of the invasion in February 2022. At the very least three deserters are identified to have been prosecuted in Russian courts.

In a report printed in November primarily based on Russian media reviews, the Institute for the Examine of Conflict, a U.S. assume tank, mentioned a whole bunch of troopers had been believed to have abandoned and had been hiding in a minimum of seven places in Ukraine’s Donetsk and Luhansk areas.

“The morale and psychological state of Russian forces within the Luhansk and Donetsk oblasts are exceedingly low,” the report mentioned. “Important losses on the battlefield, mobilization to the entrance strains with out correct coaching, and poor provides have led to instances of desertion.”

Viktoria, the spouse of one other soldier who appeared within the video, says her husband, Ivan, was despatched to the entrance line with little or no preparation. After he obtained his orders to report for obligation on October 23, she says they started shortly shopping for private gear for him: clothes, first-aid kits, berets. He was issued a sleeping bag and a uniform on the recruitment workplace.

Ivan’s unit was first despatched to Smolensk, the place they went via primary coaching, and coaching on weapons, says Viktoria, who requested that her final identify not be used.

After shifting to a sequence of places, they had been issued weapons on December 31 whereas within the Voronezh area, close to the Ukrainian border, after which they had been despatched to the entrance.. “They had been taken to Ukraine, there was no extra coaching. Nothing,” she mentioned. “They got new weapons that they’d by no means even held of their arms. They could have sat there for 3 days, after which they had been despatched to the entrance line instantly.”



Ivan instructed her that commanders ordered them to start out assaults, however Ukrainian artillery opened up, and so they ran for 7 kilometers, she says. “‘We do not even have something to defend ourselves with; no gear, nothing, simply the weapons in our arms,'” she quoted him as saying.

After that, Viktoria says, the unit started refusing orders to return to the entrance line. “They need to cost them with desertion for this. And so they say: ‘We’ve got nothing to combat with. Why ought to we go up in opposition to tanks with solely machine weapons?'” she mentioned.

“There are numerous guys, and so they all appear to be sticking collectively” as a unit, she mentioned. “However now they’re making an attempt to separate them up in order that they can not resist.”

After they had been taken out, she mentioned, the unit instructed its commanders: “We can’t go additional. It is senseless for us to go up in opposition to tanks with these weapons. What are we, cannon fodder?”

The commander then swore at them and threatened them, she says her husband instructed her: “Take off your bulletproof vests, flip over your weapons, return to your Russia. In case you get there, nicely carried out; if you do not get there, you may be MIA” — lacking in motion.

Written by Mike Eckel primarily based on reporting by Timofei Rozhanskiy of Present Time

Supply hyperlink