AI basic method, the way forward for AdTech –


Welcome to EURACTIV’s Tech Temporary, your weekly replace on all issues digital within the EU. You possibly can subscribe to the publication right here


“The Czech EU Council presidency’s ultimate compromise textual content takes under consideration the important thing considerations of the member states and preserves the fragile stability between the safety of basic rights and the promotion of uptake of AI expertise.”

Ivan Bartoš, Czechia’s Deputy Prime Minister for Digitalisation

Story of the week: The Czech presidency achieved its important victory within the digital sphere this week, as EU ministers adopted its textual content as a basic method to the AI Act. For these carefully following EURACTIV’s protection, the ultimate textual content presents no last-minute surprises. Right here it’s for these on the lookout for an outline of the principle modifications. With a caveat, as is normally the case, that the Council constructed some margin of manoeuvre to barter with MEPs, particularly in regulation enforcement.

All of the eyes are on the Parliament’s timeline now: committee vote in February and plenary vote in March. The governance and enforcement half, which is hardly controversial, has wanted 4 technical and one political assembly up to now, and the query of assets and staffing stays. This week, the article on putting AI techniques available on the market has been closed, and progress has additionally been made on the subject material, scope and ultimate provisions. However sceptics level to the truth that some controversial elements of the proposal have hardly been touched but.

Subsequent Wednesday, a possible merchandise on the agenda might be Normal Goal AI. The notorious Annex III on high-risk use instances additionally must be mentioned, however hardly anybody needs to open that dialog earlier than Christmas. One other query is whether or not the centre-right EPP will help the ultimate textual content. The environment between lawmakers has steadily improved, however the AI definition and biometric recognition would possibly lead massive chunks of the conservatives to vote negatively, weakening the Parliament’s place.

Don’t miss: The Fee’s justice and shopper division (DG JUST) has been learning the AdTech sector to arrange for an replace of the Unfair Business Practices Directive. In an unique interview, Commissioner Didier Reynders defined the principle issues the EU government is taking a look at transparency, unsubscribe course of and cookie ‘fatigue’. The thought can be to start out with a voluntary initiative as a pilot for some already referred to as the Digital Equity Act. And DG JUST shouldn’t be the one Fee service wanting on the sector. Learn extra.


Additionally this week

  • ETSI has been excluded from the draft standardisation request on the AI Act.
  • MEPs have reached a political settlement on the platform employees’ directive.
  • The Czech presidency obtained a basic method to the European digital identification.
  • The EU Council is transferring to exclude Software program-as-a-Service from the scope of the Cyber Resilience Act.
  • The EDPB choices on three instances regarding Meta’s platforms may reportedly have a dramatic influence on their enterprise mannequin.


Earlier than we begin: For those who simply can’t get sufficient tech evaluation, tune in to our weekly podcast.

Auditing algorithms

AI audits are a nascent discipline resulting from quickly growing with the adoption of the EU’s AI Act. However what are the situations for a strong auditing regime? And what are the dangers of so-called ‘audit-washing’? We talk about this and …

 Synthetic Intelligence

ETSI’s out of the sport. The Fee has excluded the European Telecommunications Requirements Institute (ETSI), one of many three European standardisation our bodies, from its draft standardisation request for the AI Act. The transfer comes as a part of broader tensions between the EU government and ETSI, which the Fee has accused of being too dominated by the non-public sector and non-European influences, the discount of which Brussels’ standard-setting technique is centred round. The most recent draft textual content, which downgrades ETSI to a consulting position, additionally incorporates another vital modifications. Learn extra.

Thoughts your bias. On Thursday, the EU’s Company for Basic Rights launched well timed analysis on AI utilized in predictive policing and content material moderation, pointing at their potential dangers of perpetuating and reinforcing biases. The company recommends the implementation of algorithm assessments earlier than and through their deployment to conclude on a case-by-case foundation whether or not these techniques are match for objective. Learn extra.

Talking of dangers. The EU’s AI Act should embrace protections for individuals on the transfer, no matter their migration standing, a coalition of over 160 civil society organisations has stated in an open letter revealed this week. The Fee’s authentic proposal, the group says, did not adequately handle potential harms resulting from utilizing AI within the context of migration, notably in areas together with predictive techniques, biometric identification and emotional recognition applied sciences.

The Customers’ Voice. The EU shopper organisation BEUC criticised the final method, saying that the definition is simply too slender, the high-risk record too restricted, efficient redress is lacking, horizontal guidelines of equity are missing, and personal entities must be banned from utilizing biometric identification.


Case closed? Amazon has reached a deal to be introduced subsequent month to conclude investigations by Brussels antitrust regulators into whether or not its knowledge use undermined rivals, together with pledged measures similar to growing the visibility of rival merchandise and including an alternate provide for consumers that deprioritises supply pace.

We don’t belief you. The US Federal Commerce Fee stated on Thursday that Microsoft’s previous behaviour relating to mergers doesn’t bode nicely for the embattled Activision acquisition at present below scrutiny by quite a few competitors authorities. For example, throughout its buy of ZeniMax Media in 2020, Microsoft reneged on guarantees made to the European Fee throughout its investigation of the deal, casting suspicion on these made in regards to the Activision one, the FTC says.

The telcos’ different. Main telecoms corporations are dealing with questions from the Fee a couple of deliberate merger that may see giants similar to Vodafone, Orange, and Deutsche Telekom be a part of forces to develop a brand new AdTech to evade monitoring restrictions carried out by Apple and Google. The challenge, which has already been regionally trialled, would see the creation of digital tokens that advertisers may use to achieve perception into consumer behaviour, a response to elevated privateness measures carried out by tech corporations.


Have your say. The Fee has revealed the public session for its suggestion to fight the piracy of reside on-line content material, aimed for implementation within the first half of subsequent 12 months. The thought is to place ahead a toolbox for combatting the offence and to encourage member states to implement their very own measures.


SaaS is out. The Council’s new compromise textual content on the Cyber Resilience Act makes an attempt to make clear the proposal’s scope. It locations Software program-as-a-Service (SaaS) firmly exterior, opposite to what member states just like the Netherlands and Germany have been asking. On the Telecom Council assembly on Tuesday, Commissioner Thierry Breton defined that together with companies like Spotify and Netflix would go towards the regulation’s authorized foundation. Nevertheless, the scope nonetheless must be totally clarified, notably in how net companies and cell apps work together with the brand new guidelines. Learn extra.

Discussing about discussing. Throughout the ministerial dialogue on the Information Act, Dutch minister Alexandra van Huffelen hit out on the cybersecurity cloud certification scheme, arguing that its sovereignty necessities may have detrimental implications for the European economic system. The decision for a political debate was seconded by Finland, Poland, Eire, Estonia and… Spain. Madrid stands out since it’s the solely nation supporting the sovereignty necessities, however because it takes the helm of the EU subsequent 12 months, they might have a vested curiosity in avoiding this scorching potato touchdown on their desk. And but, these calls elicited no response from Breton.

Winter is coming. Preparations must be made for main cyberattacks by Russia this winter, Microsoft has warned. Ongoing developments recommend that the approaching months may carry assaults on essential infrastructure and cyber-influence operations in Ukraine and throughout Europe, the corporate stated this week, setting out a plan to detect, disrupt, defend and deter such efforts within the digital sphere.

Firms’ resilience. Some 62% of organisations surveyed in Cisco’s Safety Outcomes Examine reported having skilled vital safety incidents that jeopardised enterprise operations, and 96% of executives think about cybersecurity a prime precedence.

Information & Privateness

Beginning 2023 with a increase. The European Information Safety Board (EDPB) adopted three dispute resolutions regarding Meta this week, which will likely be formalised in January. The probe was initiated by Max Schrems’ NOYB, which contested Meta’s method of not asking customers for his or her consent to course of their private knowledge for promoting functions, however thought-about that a part of a ‘contract’ because it was included within the platforms’ phrases and situations. In line with the Wall Avenue Journal, the EDPB dominated Meta’s method unlawful. Though the fines are anticipated to be notably hefty in these instances, most importantly, if the selections are confirmed, they’d undermine Meta’s whole enterprise mannequin.

Parliamentary discussions. The MEPs engaged on the Information Act within the Parliament’s business committee met on Wednesday for the primary political dialogue on the B2G data-sharing obligations. The political teams began from very distant positions on basic elements of the provisions, similar to the kind of knowledge and firms that must be concerned, however the positions have been slowly converging. In the meantime, within the inner market committee, lawmakers referred to as for political discussions on practical equivalence, limitations to switching and egress charges.

Not for me to guage. The EU Court docket of Justice has dismissed an enchantment by WhatsApp towards an EDPB ruling in August 2021 which discovered the corporate had violated the GDPR in its knowledge processing practices, leading to a €225 million superb. The EU courtroom stated the case was not admissible because the resolution was indirectly addressed to WhatsApp however to the Irish DPA. Nonetheless, a case might be introduced earlier than a nationwide courtroom.

Simply neglect it. Search engine operators are required to take away knowledge that may be confirmed inaccurate by customers from on-line search outcomes, the EU Court docket of Justice has dominated. In a case introduced by two executives in search of to uphold their proper to be forgotten on-line, the courtroom dominated that if the data is confirmed manifestly inaccurate, operators should de-reference it. Learn extra.

Clubhouse in scorching waters. Italy’s privateness watchdog has fined Clubhouse’s guardian firm €2 million for quite a few violations like an absence of transparency on knowledge use, the power for customers to retailer and share audio with out consent, the indefinite storage of audio recordings by the platform and the sharing of account data with out an ample authorized foundation.

LIBE’s timeline. The civil liberties committee plans to think about the Information Act amendments subsequent Tuesday. A shadow assembly is scheduled for 12 January, and the committee vote on 30 January.

Digital Markets Act

First workshop completed. On Monday, the primary DMA workshop came about on self-preferencing. Many media studies centered on the truth that Google’s consultant Oliver Bethell had hinted that search companies like Maps and Buying would possibly escape the DMA’s definition of core platform service. Nevertheless, maybe extra vital is that Google has publicly engaged with stakeholders for the primary time displaying their hand. Extra cynically, the workshop initiative may also be seen because the Fee making an attempt to alleviate some public stress as everybody remains to be ready for the draft secondary laws to drop.


eIDs basic method. The Council formalised its place on the European digital identification proposal this week, with compromises met throughout some areas, from document matching and assurance stage to certification and interoperability. The implementation timeline has additionally been solidified, with the Fee required to undertake acts on the regulation’s technical and operational specifics, together with cybersecurity necessities to be adopted throughout the first six months of it being in place earlier than the two-year deadline is reached. Learn extra.

You are able to do higher. In line with a report by the European Court docket of Auditors launched this week, the Fee has fallen considerably brief on its Motion Plan for digitalising public companies throughout the EU. A essential flaw within the 2016-2020 eGovernment Motion Plan, the auditors stated, was that member state motion was voluntary, and discrepancies between the digitalisation in numerous particular person international locations stay excessive. Learn extra.

eGovernance accessibility. This week noticed the publication of the Fee’s public session on the Net Accessibility Directive, an initiative designed to extend the accessibility of public-sector web sites and cell functions for susceptible residents.

Gig economic system

EMPL report approaching. Elisabetta Gualmini, the rapporteur for the platform employees’ route, advised EURACTIV {that a} political settlement had been reached within the Parliament this week, with each facet giving up on one thing. She additionally stated that, whereas most individuals have been obsessive about the rebuttable presumption, essentially the most vital a part of the proposal, in her view, is algorithmic administration. Whereas the main MEP appears assured about Monday’s committee vote, the true query mark stays the plenary. Learn extra.

No means no. EU labour and social affairs ministers met in Brussels on Thursday (8 December) hoping for an 11th-hour compromise amongst member states over the platform employees’ directive – however that failed. This follows a number of setbacks by the Czech presidency, who’d confronted a blocking minority in earlier COREPER conferences as a result of the compromise wouldn’t carry extra authorized certainty than what’s already the case in case regulation and nationwide laws.

Industrial technique

Not an excellent 12 months. In line with Atomico’s 2022 State of European Tech report, Europe’s start-up scene is falling behind. Regardless of a robust 2021 and a optimistic begin to the 12 months, the second half of 2022 noticed a major decline in funding, with late-stage corporations hit notably laborious and the variety of new unicorns dropping sharply. The tech workforce has additionally been hit laborious, and founders are having problem elevating funds, Atomico discovered, additionally pointing to the shortage of progress on variety with regards to funding.

Legislation enforcement

No continent for human rights. Final 12 months, a bunch of NGOs filed a criticism alleging that the EU had been irresponsibly contributing to growing “surveillance” capacities in third international locations, notably within the context of the Fee’s Emergency Belief Fund for Africa. The Ombudsman has concluded that the human rights implications of this challenge fell brief and that extra strong efforts should be made in future.

Wiretapping reform. Italy is in search of to reform wiretapping practices within the nation resulting from their prices and potential misuse for political positive aspects. Measures offered by Justice Minister Carlo Nordio would clamp down on wiretapping, charges of which he stated are a lot larger than the European common and which has grow to be a instrument of stress used towards each the press and political opponents. Learn extra. 

Greece’s raging scandal. MEP and chief of Greece’s socialist opposition, Nikos Androulakis, will take his nation’s authorities to the EU Court docket of Justice to search out out why he was below surveillance. Athens has admitted that secret companies tapped the politician’s cellphone however didn’t disclose the explanation by shielding behind ‘nationwide curiosity’. Learn extra. 

CSAM discipline journey. MEP Javier Zarzalejos, the rapporteur for the CSAM proposal, visited the UK’s Web Watch Basis (IWF) this week to look at how civil society organisations are serving to to deal with on-line youngster pornography.


Excellent points. The Council this week accomplished its first technical-level revision of the proposed Media Freedom Act, concluding the Czech presidency’s work on the file. The excellent points, which are actually the upcoming Swedish presidency’s accountability, have been summarised final week in a progress report, together with the regulation’s authorized foundation, scope and definitions, oversight and enforcement and provisions protecting media service suppliers. Learn extra.

Extra media bans. 4 TV channels have been included within the EU’s newest spherical of sanctions on Russia. Accused of being a part of Moscow’s “propaganda machine”, the broadcasters will likely be taken off the air and banned from different modes of distribution, very like RT and Sputnik have been in March. The channels haven’t formally been named however have been reported by Politico as being NTV/NTV Mir, RENT TV, Rossiya 1 and Pervyi Kanal.

Go away, please. Latvia has blocked unbiased Russian TV Rain from broadcasting after designating it as a nationwide safety risk. The station, which left Russia after being shut down by Moscow following the invasion of Ukraine, was fined final week for displaying a map of Russia that included occupied Crimea and describing Russian troops as “our military”. Learn extra. 

Media strike. Two non-public broadcasters in Serbia – N1 Srbija and Nova, recognized to be extremely essential of the authorities – stopped broadcasting for twenty-four hours on Tuesday in protest on the poor state of media freedom within the Western Balkan EU candidate nation. Learn extra


Committees’ competitors. The European Parliament’s Convention of Committee Chairs additionally lately authorised the inner market (IMCO) committee to conduct an own-initiative report on “Digital worlds: alternatives, dangers and coverage implications for the Single Market”. The initiative acquired the help of the EPP and S&D teams, however who will take the lead remains to be to be determined. The authorized affairs (JURI) committee may even host a listening to on the metaverse. These initiatives part of a technique to place the committee as the purpose of reference on this more and more scorching subject.

Funding announcement. On Wednesday, Meta’s prime lobbyist Nick Clegg was in Brussels to sing the praises of the metaverse and announce a €2.4 million funding in unbiased tutorial analysis on the subject. Maybe extra considerably, UK’s former deputy PM admitted that the metaverse can be way more about AR and VR.


On-line Security Invoice model 34356. The On-line Security Invoice, the UK’s reply to the DSA, was reintroduced into Parliament on Monday after being shelved in the summertime following Boris Johnson’s exit from workplace. A basic change has been made to the most recent model of the draft invoice, nevertheless, following criticism from some that its provisions regarding “authorized however dangerous” materials would result in the over-removal of content material by platforms, posing a risk to freedom of speech. Final week, the federal government introduced that these invoice components can be eliminated, that means corporations would now not be required to have insurance policies protecting this materials regarding grownup customers. Nevertheless, they are going to nonetheless apply to kids.

Empowering customers. A new examine by the Shopper Empowerment Challenge, backed by Euroconsumers and Google, has discovered that buyers total really feel that the position of digital companies of their lives is a optimistic one. Nonetheless, that lack of understanding or belief in suppliers have been two of essentially the most vital limitations to utilising companies, and that generational and socio-economic gaps stay.

Analysis & Innovation

Subsequent two years’ programme. The principle Horizon Europe work programme 2023-24 was adopted this week, offering roughly €13.5 billion in funding for researchers and innovators throughout Europe.

EIC in 2023. The 2023 work programme of the European Innovation Council (EIC) has been adopted, making €1.6 billion value of funding accessible for scientists and innovators.

Defence funding. The Fee this week gave the inexperienced mild to an funding of round €1.2 billion to fund analysis tasks centered on high-end defence capabilities.


One other week, one other letter. Germany, Austria, Estonia, Finland, Eire and the Netherlands have all joined a name for the Fee to make clear its plans to make Large Tech corporations contribute to telecoms community prices, notably asking for it to be handled individually from the revision of the Broadband Value Discount Route – which EURACTIV understands was already the case. Learn extra.

Transatlantic ties

Commerce conflict or not? On the post-TTC press convention, anybody agreed an EU-US commerce conflict must be prevented. Nonetheless, the query stays that the US Congress’ intention is exactly that of subsidising the American business – and it’s certainly the one factor US lawmakers appear capable of agree on. The EU’s Cyber certification scheme was mentioned on the latest transatlantic Commerce and Know-how Council, US Secretary of Commerce Gina Raimondo confirmed with out giving any particulars.

Biden’s commerce ambitions. Boldened by the mid-term elections, US President Joe Biden is alleged to be poised to ask Congress for the powers to barter commerce agreements – which appears unlikely. The Biden administration is thirsty for international coverage victories, and its plan would flip the TTC right into a platform to barter a brand new commerce settlement with the EU. Nevertheless, Europeans have proven little urge for food for that.

Twin transitions

Apple’s model of Right2Repair. Apple launched a self-service restore programme in eight European international locations this week, making manuals and product elements accessible to prospects wishing to undertake their very own repairs. The Proper to Restore marketing campaign has hit again on the measure, which follows the same pilot within the US, arguing that its scope is slender and geographically restricted, its prices in depth and procedures complicated.


What else we’re studying this week:

A globally essential chip agency is driving a wedge between the U.S. and Netherlands over China tech coverage (CNBC)

The Brilliance and Weirdness of ChatGPT (The New York Occasions)

Theo Bourgery-Gonse contributed to the reporting.

Supply hyperlink